Category
26 articles
Since the 1950s, sociologists have been absolutely certain they knew exactly how Americans would arrange themselves under a single roof. They were wrong in every direction—sometimes predicting the death of the family unit, sometimes its glorious communal resurrection, and occasionally both at once.
Beginning in the early 1960s, economists and futurists declared with remarkable consistency that prosperity and automation would soon deliver Americans into a golden age of leisure—a retirement boom that would redefine what it meant to grow old in the richest nation on earth. Americans, for the most part, kept showing up to work.
For a full century, economists, engineers, and excitable journalists have been warning that the machines were finally coming for our jobs — for real this time. The machines arrived. The jobs changed. Then we invented several thousand new jobs to manage the machines, worry about the machines, and write think pieces about the machines.
For fifty years, futurists have been confidently predicting that American workers were about to abandon their downtown offices forever. Some predicted it in 1973. Some predicted it in 2020. The office, battered and bewildered, is still there — and somehow rents in Manhattan have never been higher.
Since the early 1980s, a succession of financial prophets, self-help authors, and investment newsletter editors have assured Americans that radical early retirement was not only possible but practically inevitable — for anyone willing to follow a simple system. The system kept changing. The retirement kept not happening.
Since the 1970s, a dedicated corps of environmentalists, scientists, and alarmed magazine editors has been issuing the planet specific, dated ultimatums — extinction by this year, ecological collapse by that one, irreversible tipping points by the next. The planet has declined every appointment. The question of what this tells us about the art of prophecy is more interesting than the doomsayers would like.
Depending on which decade you asked and which expert held the microphone, television was either the destroyer of the American mind or the salvation of the American republic. Sometimes it was both, occasionally in the same magazine. The story of TV prophecy is really a story about experts who needed to calm down.
For most of the twentieth century, America's most credentialed economists looked at rising productivity and made a perfectly reasonable, completely catastrophic prediction: that prosperity would soon deliver everyone a twenty-hour workweek and oceans of glorious free time. The average American is now working more hours than when the promises started. This is the story of the most optimistic forecast in economic history, and how it aged.
From the moment the first kid nailed a plank to some roller skate wheels, respectable adults have been confidently announcing that skateboarding was moments away from embarrassing itself into extinction. Those adults are now watching skateboarding at the Olympics. This is their story, and it is not flattering.
In the 1980s, retail visionaries declared the enclosed shopping mall the eternal crown jewel of American civilization — a climate-controlled paradise that would only multiply and conquer. Then Sears turned off the lights, the food courts went quiet, and someone opened a trampoline park where the Mervyn's used to be.
For well over a century, a rotating cast of linguists, newspaper columnists, schoolteachers, and professionally scandalized grandparents have issued solemn warnings that the latest generation's slang would permanently corrupt the English language beyond all recognition. The flappers' 'bee's knees' is now charming. 'LOL' is in the dictionary. The language survives.
In the 1980s, America's leading economic minds were so certain Japan would swallow the U.S. economy whole that bestselling books, Senate hearings, and panicked magazine covers all delivered the same verdict: start practicing your bowing technique. Then Japan's bubble popped, the dot-com boom happened, and the prophets of Tokyo's inevitable triumph went very, very quiet.
Every generation since Eisenhower has produced a fresh set of experts warning that the latest sedentary technology — the car, the remote control, the smartphone — was finally going to complete humanity's evolutionary surrender to the horizontal. Every generation also produced a new fitness craze to feel guilty about not doing. The Americans are still, technically, bipedal.
In the 1980s, state officials promised that lottery revenues would transform America's schools into gleaming temples of learning. The reality turned out to be significantly more creative accounting than educational revolution.
For four decades, America's economic prophets have confidently called the next Great Depression every eighteen months with charts, graphs, and very serious faces. Their track record suggests astrology might be more reliable.
From Senate hearings to pediatric panic, America's establishment spent decades warning that video games would create a generation of brain-dead sociopaths. Instead, those Mortal Kombat kids grew up to build the internet and save lives as doctors.
After every landslide election, America's political fortune tellers declare one party permanently dominant and the other forever doomed. They've been wrong so consistently that their predictions have become the political equivalent of a stopped clock — occasionally right by accident, but mostly just taking up space.
Paul Ehrlich's 1968 bestseller promised mass starvation and societal collapse by the 1980s. Instead, humanity kept doing that annoying thing where it solves problems and feeds more people. Here's how the century's most confident doomsday prediction became a masterclass in spectacular wrongness.
Mid-century urban planners and social theorists were absolutely certain Americans would abandon supermarkets for communal kitchens and government food dispensaries. They underestimated our deep, abiding love affair with having seventeen types of mustard available at 2 AM.
Financial analysts and market prophets have been predicting the definitive, civilization-ending stock market collapse every single year since the Truman administration. The market, meanwhile, has spent seven decades doing whatever it wanted anyway.
The Anti-Saloon League and Women's Christian Temperance Union didn't just want to ban alcohol — they promised it would empty prisons, fill factories, and transform America into a crime-free wonderland. They were half right about transformation.
For decades, America's brightest economic minds confidently proclaimed they'd tamed the inflation beast forever. Then 2022 walked in and made grocery shopping feel like a luxury sport.
Since the 1970s, America's smartest urban planners have been absolutely certain that suburbs were finished. Then came 2020, and Americans fled cities faster than you could say 'two-car garage.'
For forty years, politicians and preachers warned that legalizing gambling would transform America into a coast-to-coast casino wasteland. Instead, most states just collected the tax revenue and moved on.
Radio would kill novels, television would kill radio, video games would kill television, and social media would kill everything. Yet somehow, Americans keep reading more books than ever, defying a century of confident predictions about literature's imminent demise.
For four decades, criminologists and politicians warned Americans that crime waves would swallow our cities whole. Then the 1990s happened, crime plummeted, and the doomsayers quietly shuffled their PowerPoint slides into the trash.